HomeNewsCity of Augusta spent thousands for outsourced attorney to fight media

City of Augusta spent thousands for outsourced attorney to fight media

Author

Date

Augusta Finance Department records show the city of Augusta paid an Atlanta law firm $21,066.50 for consulting services related to several matters involving disputes with local news organizations over the Georgia Open Records Act.

Augusta Commission meeting minutes do not reflect that the body officially approved paying the consulting fees to Dentons US LLP for its services in regard to a 2021 case, The Augusta Press et al. v. The City of Augusta.

MORE: Davis and former aid deny ethics allegations; former employee says mayor knows more

Invoices as well as an email from City Attorney Wayne Brown to Finance Director Donna Wiliams show that it was Augusta Mayor Hardie Davis Jr. who requested the firm, led by former Georgia Attorney General Samuel Olens.

In the email to Williams, Brown claims the charges on the invoices were “incurred by Mayor Davis.”

MORE: Anti-cheating software transcript reveals more details about AU basketball scandal

Finance records show the Olens was paid $14,696.50 for consultation in the suit filed in April 2021. However, Olens was not listed as co-counsel in any court documents and never attended any of the three hearings that were held in the case.

The lawsuit was filed in Richmond County Superior Court to compel the city to turn over public documents related to the search for a new fire chief. Judge Jesse Stone found the city in violation of the open records and ruled for the plaintiffs which included The Augusta Press, The Augusta Chronicle, WRDW television and WJBF television.

The city also paid Olens $5,265 for consulting in another ongoing matter involving the open records law.

The Augusta Press has repeatedly requested emails sent from Davis’ private email account that pertain to city business. At first, the mayor claimed no such emails existed. He later changed his story and said some emails might exist, but that they were on his private account and therefore not subject to the law.

Olens attended a meeting in June 2021 with Wayne Brown, David Hudson, attorney for The Augusta Press, Joe Edge, publisher of The Augusta Press and Petula Burks, the mayor’s chief of staff to discuss the law pertaining to the emails and other documents that had been requested. Davis did not attend the meeting.

MORE: Grovetown residents concerned about possible rezoning

In the meeting, which was recorded, Olens told Brown if such emails did indeed exist, then they were subject to the Open Records Act and the city should comply with the request. However, Olens also added there was no stipulation in the law that the mayor give total access to his private email without a warrant.

So far the city has not heeded Olens’ advice in turning over multiple requests for documents and emails and according to Edge, the ongoing dispute is likely headed to court if the city does not reverse its position and comply with the law.

Some Augusta Commissioners appeared to be broadsided by hearing of the total expenses paid in legal consulting fees. The city paid Olen nearly $15,000 for advice, in comparison, the total bill submitted to The Augusta Press for legal services throughout the entire court case amounted to less than $10,000, according to Edge.

District 10 Commissioner John Clarke did not remember ever voting on paying the fees and said if he had been presented with the amounts due, he certainly would have had questions.

“I think it’s ludicrous that we are paying someone to explain the law to our own attorney,” Clarke said.

MORE: Column: Greg Rickabaugh looks back at the bad deeds that had everyone talking in 2021

According to District 3 Commissioner Catherine Smith-McKnight, the matter did briefly come up in a legal meeting, but the information presented was vague at best.

“I had no idea they were using someone from Atlanta when we have plenty of fine attorneys here in Augusta,” she said.

District 8 Commissioner Brandon Garrett also remembered the conversation, but said it seemed to be an “umbrella request,” and he did not recall being given the specifics either.

In the email to Donna Williams, Brown stated the commission had authorized the payments, however, such a vote was never recorded in the minutes of the Oct. 12 meeting. The Clerk of Commissions Office could also not find a record of such a vote.

Meanwhile, in related news, Davis’ former private attorney Ed Tarver complied with a request and sent a copy of Davis’ private emails that prove Davis does use the account to conduct city related business, avoiding the Open Records Law.

The letter from Tarver also stated that due to a possible conflict of interest his firm no longer represents Davis.

Scott Hudson is the Senior Reporter for The Augusta Press. Reach him at [email protected].

16 COMMENTS

  1. I’m confused about one point. Were any payments made directly to Olens personally or were all pmts made to his firm, Dentons US LLP? Why is H Davis always trying to hide communications? I guess the answer to that is pretty obvious. Great work Scott Hudson and The Augusta Press, keep it up!

    • Payments were made to the law firm. The invoices were addressed to the mayor’s office. We monitor his finances very closely. we look at every charge so had it been paid out of his account we would have saw it before. The city lawyer asked for it to be paid out of his account in closed session. It is unclear why. What is clear is that commissioners were not given a fair and clear picture on what the bill was for. They were not told what law firm, that it was for the mayor or the amount. It is also unclear if a vote by the commission in public was required since it was approved in legal session, but nothing shows up in the commission minutes.

  2. Thanks to the city for looking out in the best interest of the taxpayers..sarcasm of course. Why isn’t anything done? All ten commissioners should be beating the doors down to correct this action. I love my city but damn the government makes it hard. Not that most care but disappointed again. Thanks to the Augusta Press for staying on that ass!

  3. Except for two or three commissioners we need to clean house. Hizzoner should have already been gone. Thank God for term limits! The end of his term can’t come soon enough. And I also hope there is a resolution soon to the Sammy Sias problem so we can quit paying him.

  4. Can anyone in law enforcement or the judiciary explain to us why Hardie Davis has not been indicted and tried for violating about a half-dozen laws concerning elected officials and misuse of public funds?

  5. Folks in RC have to know they’re stuck with crooked politicians for life. Too many ignorant voters who don’t care to know what’s going on. The new DA would never pursue an indictment and neither will the feds under this administration. Maybe the state AG???

  6. I’m sure Michael will tell us what a fine job the mayor does in his next piece. It’s hard for me to believe Hardie can just keep thumbing his nose at the law and the taxpayers and zilch is done about it…

Recent posts

Recent comments

Juliann McCraney on Column: Faith: Ups and downs
Robert Schloesser on Saga with Gold Cross EMS continues
Thomas Yarbrough on Garnett Johnson: In his own words
Tedd Antonacci on OPINION: Letter to the editor
Charmain Brackett on Reoccurring Members
Charmain Brackett on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Russell Smeak on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Trudy Edwards on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Gay Wright on Reoccurring Members
Russell Smeak on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Charmain Brackett on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Charmain Brackett on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Russell Smeak on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Thomas Plowden on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Charmain Brackett on Man struck by train Thursday
Thomas Yarbrough on Man struck by train Thursday
Tedd Antonacci on Man struck by train Thursday
Dennis Perry on FAITH: Our Only Hope
Robert Turbyfill on Column: Serene18 – take two
Leonard Zimmerman Jr on In The Kitchen With Vera: Oh Honey
Tedd Antonacci on Bomb threat suspect in custody
Frank Bush on FAITH: A Great Lady
Judy Wheeler on FAITH: A Great Lady
Robert Green on Kemp signs tax cut bill
Dan Barnett on FAITH: The Turtle
William Speer on Whither Ukraine?
Sherri Jones Rivers on FAITH: The Turtle
Judy Wheeler on FAITH: The Turtle
Doug Herman on Whither Ukraine?
Phillip Williams on Column: Electing judges
John Mulherin on Column: Electing judges
Sarah Scott on Column: Electing judges
Thomas Yarbrough on XPR Augusta Concerts Canceled
Bill Lesshafft on XPR Augusta Concerts Canceled
Amanda Main on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Tedd Antonacci on XPR Augusta Concerts Canceled
Rev. Bill Harrell on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Jackie VOSS on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Penny Danner on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Rabbi David Sirull on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Allen Wylds on