HomeOpinionLetters to the EditorConfederate Memorial Letter to Editor

Confederate Memorial Letter to Editor

Author

Date

Dear Editor,

Augusta’s Confederate Monuments and Landmarks Task Force has recently made public its recommendations to the city government, one of which is the removal of the “Confederate Monument” from Broad Street. Mayor Davis is to be commended for approaching the volatile issue of historic structures and names in such a measured and reasonable manner. But I think there is a much better solution than moving the existing monument. Instead, leave this statue in place but also erect an equally grand and prominent monument, perhaps on upper Broad Street, to the Black struggle for equality and to their contributions to our community and country.

[adrotate banner=”19″]

We should note that while Springfield Village Park already recognizes the rich heritage of the historic church of that name and other Black citizens of Augusta, we lack a suitably prominent monument to recognize the magnitude of what Augusta’s Black citizens have suffered through the injustices of slavery, Jim Crow, segregation, discrimination and racism. Nor do we have an appropriate monument to recognize the importance of what they have contributed to our city’s long history. Why don’t we work together to build a grand counterpoint to the Confederate Memorial, perhaps on upper Broad Street, to honor of our Black citizens? Would not these complementary bookends better reflect the hopes and aspirations of Augusta today? Wouldn’t it be better for us all to work together constructively to make our city better? I believe that such an effort would enjoy such broad and enthusiastic support that it may well be done with private funds and no cost to the city. I ask the Augusta Commissioners to give this proposal consideration.

Let me also take a moment to give some background on the memorial. The “Confederate Monument” was not built as a monument to the Confederacy, rather it was to be a memorial to Augusta’s Confederate dead and is properly known as the “Augusta Confederate Memorial.” It is essentially a tombstone. It is also the most magnificent work of public art in Augusta.

At the end of the brutal Civil War, many of Augusta’s young men lay dead in graves scattered among battlefields, hospitals, and prisoner of war camps throughout the South and into the North. In early 1868, shortly after the Civil War ended, the Augusta’s Ladies Memorial Association began an effort to erect a memorial to the city’s war dead. The Ladies Memorial Association sprang from an earlier organization which during the war had provided clothing, food and shelter to soldiers, and after the war provided for the destitute families of servicemen killed or disabled in the conflict. They and similar organizations throughout the South collected the dead, brought them home to be buried and provided headstones for their graves. In order that those who had died in the war not be forgotten, they decided to build a memorial in their honor. The association initiated a fundraising effort which eventually involved churches, synagogues, schools, social and civic organizations. After several years of conducting fairs, bazaars, raffles and every imaginable method of raising money, sufficient amounts were raised to commission a monument.

[adrotate banner=”23″]

The monument on Broad Street was finally designed, sculpted by artists in Italy, shipped to Augusta and finally dedicated on October 31, 1878, capping ten years of effort. The striking Carrera marble monument is one of the finest examples of public statuary in Georgia and, perhaps uniquely, the figure at top is a private soldier standing at parade rest above four Confederate generals. The soldier, intended to an anonymous figure representing all common Southern soldiers, was widely believed to be modeled on Pvt. Berry Benson of Augusta. He stands above Generals Lee, Jackson, Cobb and Walker. Similar memorials have been erected all over our country following every war we have fought.

The Rev. General Clement A. Evans, a former Confederate officer and later pastor of St. John’s Methodist Church, delivered the oration at the laying of the cornerstone, and gave a message of reconciliation between North and South. He said that the purpose of the monument was not to assert continued adherence to the cause of secession but to honor the service of the individual soldiers who had given their lives in defense of their homes and families. The monument acknowledged the extinction of the Confederate cause and the acceptance of reunification with the North. He said, “…the voice of this monument will not be for war but for peace.”

Tennent Houston

Past President, Historic Augusta, Inc.

[adrotate banner=”17″]

3 COMMENTS

    • Mr. Houston has an excellent idea. Rather than tearing down what has always been a memorial to our local dead, build a memorial to our other locals who lack one. This memorial was not built during the 20th century to glorify the Confederacy as were some statues being removed. It was erected right after the war to honor those who died. All over the world, memorials to the dead from both sides of wars are allowed to remain forever. This should not be any different.

  1. Let us not divide ourselves by trying to erase history. My great-great grand uncle, William Hoover Rihl, was the first Union soldier to be killed north of the Mason -Dixon Line, in Greencastle, PA, about three miles north of the Maryland border. He and two also untrained others, engaged a battle hardened sixteen member Confederate patrol who were feeding their horses at at secession friendly farmhouse who were scoping out the area for the impending invasion of the impending Confederate invasion of Pennsylvania, which at that time had never committed troops to the Union Army. My Uncle Bill had joined a New York unit, although from Philadelphia. Pennsylvania was devided and most thought that The South shoud go its own way.
    In the meantime, my other great-great grand uncle, originally from Franklin County, VA, but having moved to Florida, was Captain Jon Talbot Bernard, and he was Robert E. Lee’s Ordinance Train Commander. The Bernard’s, from near Roanoke, VA, wee railroad people, I knew their grandchildren, and Uncle Jon probably supplied the bullet, that killed my other great-grend uncle Bill.
    Neither one of these people owned slaves or hated black people. So don’t be anachronistic and start tearing down statues because you don’t like wars that happened a couple of hundred years ago over issues that don’t even exist today. Confederates were Americans too, a lot better ones than some of the ones we have today. Let all of our historic heroes have their place in history.
    Robert H. Rihl

Recent posts

Recent comments

Tedd Antonacci on Bomb threat suspect in custody
Frank Bush on FAITH: A Great Lady
Judy Wheeler on FAITH: A Great Lady
Robert Green on Kemp signs tax cut bill
Dan Barnett on FAITH: The Turtle
William Speer on Whither Ukraine?
Sherri Jones Rivers on FAITH: The Turtle
Judy Wheeler on FAITH: The Turtle
Doug Herman on Whither Ukraine?
Phillip Williams on Column: Electing judges
John Mulherin on Column: Electing judges
Sarah Scott on Column: Electing judges
Thomas Yarbrough on XPR Augusta Concerts Canceled
Bill Lesshafft on XPR Augusta Concerts Canceled
Amanda Main on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Tedd Antonacci on XPR Augusta Concerts Canceled
Rev. Bill Harrell on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Jackie VOSS on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Penny Danner on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Rabbi David Sirull on FAITH: The Covid Effect
Elizabeth Ristroph on Michael Meyers: The Law Allows It
Phillip Williams on Michael Meyers: The Law Allows It
Debbie Reddin Van Tuyll on For America, a free press is not optional
Debbie Reddin Van Tuyll on For America, a free press is not optional
Barry Paschal on Dine & Dish: Banh Mi Dang
Steve Brett on Broad Street Reimagined
Jeff Simless on Broad Street Reimagined
Leonard Zimmerman Jr on Augusta Museum of History to expand
James Colton on RUSSIA: WHAT NEXT?
Jim Claffey on Broad Street Reimagined
Thomas Plowden on Broad Street Reimagined
Bill Lesshafft on Broad Street Reimagined
Tedd Antonacci on Broad Street Reimagined
John Barney on Broad Street Reimagined
Rick Acree on Broad Street Reimagined
Eric Feldkamp on Broad Street Reimagined
Phillip Williams on Old Warrenton Studios shut down
Christine Slendak on Old Warrenton Studios shut down
Thomas Yarbrough on MCG study focuses on long COVID
Sylvia Cooper on FAITH: Wasps on the Tower
John Barney on RUSSIA: WHAT NEXT?
Gary Smith on RUSSIA: WHAT NEXT?
THOMAS SUMNER on RUSSIA: WHAT NEXT?
Juliann McCraney on FAITH: Wasps on the Tower