HomeNewsGeorgia Power critics want less coal, more renewables

Georgia Power critics want less coal, more renewables

Author

Date

by Dave Williams | Jul 15, 2022 | Capitol Beat News Service

ATLANTA – Georgia Power’s latest plan for meeting the electrical-generation needs of its customers would keep the Atlanta-based utility on a path toward relying less on burning coal and more on renewable energy.

But environmental and consumer advocates are asking the state Public Service Commission to require Georgia Power to do more when the PSC votes July 21 on the utility’s 2022 Integrated Resource Plan, an update the company submits every three years outlining its planned mix of energy sources for the next two decades.

Specifically, the plan’s critics want the commission to order Georgia Power to:

  • Retire two coal-burning units at Plant Bowen near Cartersville, in addition to other coal units at Bowen and several other power plants around the state the utility already is proposing to close in the IRP.
  • Reject at least one of six natural gas power purchasing agreements Georgia Power plans to pursue.
  • Double the commitment the utility made in the resource plan to develop an additional 2,300 megawatts of solar power.
  • Lift a cap limiting Georgia Power’s rooftop solar pilot project to 5,000 customers.
  • Reinstitute Georgia Power’s commitment in the IRP it submitted last January to a 1,000-megawatt battery storage project, which the utility dropped last month in an agreement with the PSC’s Public Interest Advocacy Staff.
  • Reject Georgia’s Power’s plan for closing its network of coal ash ponds, which would leave some ash stored in unlined pits in contact with groundwater.

If the commission approves the plan in its current form, Georgia Power would fall short of its own stated long-term goals, a coalition of leaders of college student-run organizations across the state focused on environmental issues wrote in a statement submitted to the commission July 2.

“While our current expansion of clean energy provides us hope, it is not moving nearly fast enough to avoid climate change’s worst impacts,” the students wrote.

“Their plan will maintain our heavy reliance on fossil fuels for the next 20 years, despite [Georgia Power parent] Southern Company’s commitment to net-zero emissions.”

Georgia Power should go all-in on its plan to retire its fleet of coal-burning power plants, including the two units at Plant Bowen, because they’re simply not economical in today’s era of stricter government regulation of carbon emissions, Robert Jackson, a lawyer for the Sierra Club, told members of the PSC’s Energy Committee July 14.

But doing away with the entire coal plant fleet got some pushback during that hearing from Clay Jones, a lawyer for the Georgia Association of Manufacturers, one of the parties that signed on to last month’s agreement.

“You’re already approving a significant retirement of coal assets,” Jones told commissioners. “We believe maintaining Bowen Units 1 and 2 provides a key hedge against overreliance on volatile natural gas prices.”

Katie Southworth, advocacy program director at the Atlanta-based sustainability organization Southface Energy Institute, said if Georgia Power continues operating the two coal units at Plant Bowen beyond 2027, it wouldn’t need the gas power purchasing agreements.

The Sierra Club is calling on the PSC to require Georgia Power to double its commitment to renewable energy sources including solar and wind power.

But Simon Mahan, executive director of the Southern Renewable Energy Association, said an inadequate transmission system is an obstacle to Georgia Power significantly expanding its portfolio of renewables.

“The company is having difficulty retiring uneconomic power plants without a robust transmission system,” he said. “Building transmission would better enable the commission to adopt more low-cost renewables sooner rather than later.”

Jill Kysor, a lawyer representing the Atlanta-based Southern Environmental Law Center, said another obstacle to the expansion of renewables in Georgia is the cap on Georgia Power’s rooftop solar program. She suggested doing away with cap entirely rather than raising it from the current 5,000 customers.

“If the cap is increased but the number is too small, we’ll just have a rush into the program,” Kysor said. “Certain types of customers, like churches or middle-income families, that take longer to make decisions won’t be able to react quickly and get into the program.”

The PSC debated the cap issue last year when the program proved so popular the number of participating customers was threatening to bump up against the cap.

Brandon Marzo, a lawyer representing Georgia Power, said lifting the cap on the rooftop solar program would lead to an unacceptable shifting of costs to customers not participating in the program.

“You’re going to ask customers who are not providing the service to pay for it,” Marzo told commissioners during the July 14 hearing.

Brad Carver, a lawyer representing the Large-Scale Solar Association, asked the PSC not to let Georgia Power back away from its January proposal to develop 1,000 megawatts of power through innovative battery storage technology.

After the utility raised concerns over whether the project’s potential benefits would justify the cost, the project was dropped in the agreement reached last month.

“Investments in storage are the way to help our transmission constraints,” Carver said.

Jackson asked commissioners not to let Georgia Power leave the coal ash in some of the ash ponds it is planning to close in unlined pits in contact with groundwater, a practice he said is illegal under both state and federal law.

The Sierra Club fought Georgia Power’s two-pronged plan to remove the ash from some ponds and leave it in place in others all the way to the state Supreme Court, which has declined to hear the case.

“Closure in place and closure by removal are acceptable and protective of human health and the environment if performed correctly,” Marzo said.

At the July 14 hearing, Marzo urged commissioners not to make any changes in the stipulation agreement reached last month.

“All the provisions in the stipulation have been negotiated,” he said. “Any change in one provision could affect the balance of the bargain.”

But Commissioner Tim Echols noted the PSC has a history of changing Georgia Power IRPs.

“In every single IRP that we’ve had since 2013, this commission has done more solar than you all wanted to do,” Echols told Marzo.

At the end of the hearing, Echols hinted that rooftop solar could be among the changes the PSC imposes on the utility. He said raising the cap on the program to 75,000 customers would generate 500 megawatts of solar power in the more populated northern half of Georgia.

“That would allow us to get some additional solar on the grid north of I-20,” he said. “Wouldn’t that help with reliability in North Georgia?”

This story is available through a news partnership with Capitol Beat News Service, a project of the Georgia Press Educational Foundation.

5 COMMENTS

  1. Environmentalists are a really “dense” bunch of people. I’m trying to be nice. They believe that the US is to blame for ALL of the ills of the planet. Southern Company is moving towards a “greener” footprint, but it takes time. You can not just “snap your fingers/wiggle your nose” and things will be “GREEN”. This is not “Bewitched”. If you will remember, the environmentalists and their “study” held up the construction start for Units #3 and #4 for Plant Vogtle. Our CURRENT power production is light-years “greener” than China, India, or Russia. Give it a damn rest. When Georgia Power and Savannah Electric and Power companies were my customers, things were much dirtier back then. Oil was replaced with natural gas. Environmentalists will also be the first ones to complain that the “per kilo-watt hour rate” is too high for their EVs. You cannot have it both ways. Sit down and shut up, and let Southern Company do their thing, without YOU getting in the way.

  2. Obviously none of these “environmentalist” know how electrical generation works. Electricity isn’t this magical energy that comes from magic. Even the head of the department of energy has admitted that the electric vehicles being pushed onto the public will have to have fossil fuels to make the charging stations viable. Besides that? You’ll be costing Americans jobs while Russia and China dump whatever they please into the air and waterways. I’m all for being as clean as we can be but being the only place taking the biggest hit makes us lose competitive manufacturing and will make us weaker economically and embolden our foreign competition. This is just dumb..

  3. I could write an essay about how dumb these environmentalists are, with proof, but Rip and Allen have done a very good job to open your eyes already. We are moving plenty fast enough, and actually need to slow down the taking away from one industry and giving to another just for the sake of lining the Lawyers pockets and the new crooks’ pockets at the cost to the current employees and owners in the old but reliable coal industry. And all ash pits should have been cleaned up years ago.

  4. We should follow Sri Lanka’s example! They have become an Organic Paradise getting rid of all forms of energy except Solar and Wind power! It’s a beautiful thing! (of course, their people are starving but hey, what’s a little pain when it comes to saving the planet, right? We may not live to enjoy it but somehow it’ll be worth it)

Recent posts

Recent comments

Pierce Blitch III on Augusta barber tradition continues
Tedd Antonacci on Bon Air receives failing grade
Catherine McKnight on Bon Air receives failing grade
Carolyn Vickers on Pay going up for city employees
Clarence Powell on Pay going up for city employees
Thomas Yarbrough on Pay going up for city employees
Leza Witherington on Pay going up for city employees
J. Paul Griffin on Pay going up for city employees
Catherine McKnight on Sias found guilty of federal crimes
Dianne Lackey on Dine and Dish: Calvert’s
Jimmy Clark on Faith: Swift retribution
Penny Danner on Faith: Swift retribution
Kevin de l’Aigle on Arrest made in transgender slaying
Barry Paschal on Dine and Dish: Calvert’s
THOMAS SUMNER on Dine and Dish: Calvert’s
Christine Slendak on Gold Cross increase request fails
Thomas Yarbrough on Murder suspect arrested
Thomas Yarbrough on Columbia County inmate dies
Thomas Yarbrough on Operation Grace leads to arrests
Thomas Yarbrough on Operation Grace leads to arrests
Phillip Williams on Operation Grace leads to arrests
Tedd Antonacci on Opinion: Letter to the editor
NancyBlumenthal on “Augusta” By David Sirull
Kelly Wagner on Another homicide in Augusta
Juliann McCraney on Column: Faith: Ups and downs
Robert Schloesser on Saga with Gold Cross EMS continues
Thomas Yarbrough on Garnett Johnson: In his own words
Tedd Antonacci on OPINION: Letter to the editor
Charmain Brackett on Reoccurring Members
Charmain Brackett on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Russell Smeak on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Trudy Edwards on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Gay Wright on Reoccurring Members
Russell Smeak on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Charmain Brackett on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Charmain Brackett on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Russell Smeak on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Thomas Plowden on Short Getaways: Edisto Beach
Charmain Brackett on Man struck by train Thursday
Thomas Yarbrough on Man struck by train Thursday
Tedd Antonacci on Man struck by train Thursday
Dennis Perry on FAITH: Our Only Hope
Nona Zimmerman on Amy Grant at the Miller May 25
Robert Turbyfill on Column: Serene18 – take two
Leonard Zimmerman Jr on In The Kitchen With Vera: Oh Honey