Dog thieves arrested for stealing pet while working in Evans

James Crumpley, 47, and Emily Cutlip, 55, were charged Tuesday with felony theft by taking in the Dec. 22 dog theft.

Date: January 04, 2023

Columbia County authorities have arrested a couple who allegedly stole a dog from the home of an Evans pediatrician just before Christmas.

James Crumpley, 47, and Emily Cutlip, 55, were charged Tuesday with felony theft by taking in the Dec. 22 dog theft.

According to a sheriff’s report, the suspects were working Dec. 22 as painters on a home near the residence of the victim, Dr. Margaret Renew, who is a well-known pediatrician. The victim said she had friends and family over when her Cavalier King Charles Spaniel dog named “JoJo” went missing.


MORE: Hephzibah man wanted for stealing trailer with old jukebox & more


A tracking dog came out and tracked the scent of “JoJo” over to the neighbor’s home, where a worker seemed “disinterested” when asked if he had seen her dog, a report says.

Dr. Renew and her husband, Tom Renew, posted about the missing animal and offered a reward. The animal was dropped off Tuesday at 15th street and Morgan Street in Augusta and the suspects arrested the same day. Online posts of the victims being reunited shows Dr. Renew in tears as she hugs those who helped in the search.

A sheriff’s report lists the suspects’ home address as 1049 Ridge Spring Highway in Ward, S.C., and says they work as painters for a home building company out of North Augusta.

Greg Rickabaugh is the Jail Report contributor for The Augusta Press. Reach him at greg.rickabaugh@theaugustapress.com 

What to Read Next

The Author

Greg Rickabaugh is an award-winning crime reporter in the Augusta-Aiken area with experience writing for The Augusta Chronicle and serving as publisher of The Jail Report. He also owns AugustaCrime.com. Rickabaugh is a 1994 graduate of the University of South Carolina and has appeared on several crime documentaries on the Investigation Discovery channel. He is married with two daughters.

Comment Policy

The Augusta Press encourages and welcomes reader comments; however, we request this be done in a respectful manner, and we retain the discretion to determine which comments violate our comment policy. We also reserve the right to hide, remove and/or not allow your comments to be posted.

The types of comments not allowed on our site include:

  • Threats of harm or violence
  • Profanity, obscenity, or vulgarity, including images of or links to such material
  • Racist comments
  • Victim shaming and/or blaming
  • Name calling and/or personal attacks;
  • Comments whose main purpose are to sell a product or promote commercial websites or services;
  • Comments that infringe on copyrights;
  • Spam comments, such as the same comment posted repeatedly on a profile.